"Emmaus never happened. Emmaus always happens"
James Dominic Crossan on Luke 24:13-32 in Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography.
Again, I'm not saying it is agreeable, simply memorable!
posted by Chris Tilling @ 1:16 AM
i could swear i read this quote somewhere else, but i do have that book so maybe that's where it was from. quite memorable
I'm pretty sure his name's John Domininc Crossan.
Crossan didn't say that. Crossan always says that!
Oh, Crossan. That crazy cat. So mysterious.
I think this is a pericope very much like that of the woman caught in adultery: whether or not it actually happened, it clearly belongs to our store of Biblical resources for understanding the gospel message.
Is it objective/subjective question of truth? Did it really happen?
Didn't NT Wright quote it too in Jesus and the Victory of God (I think)?
I fliipin called him "James" ?????????? ????????????????????????? ??????????? ??????????OK, I was tired last night!Let's face it, that JOHN Dominic Crossan can be wonderfully eloquent.I found this quote in a Borg chapter in The Meaning of Jesus, though I am sure it is quoted in a number of places.
James:Wright quotes it in The Resurrection of the Son of God. I just happened to read that page today.
I suspect that Crossan's proposition was inspired by this passage from the prologue to the first novel Thomas Mann's Joseph Tetralogy, The Tales of Jacob: "For it is, always is, however much we may say It was . Thus speaks the myth, which is only the garment of the mystery . But the holiday garment of the mystery is the feast, the recurrent feast which bestrides the tenses and makes the has-been and the to-be present to the popular sense."
I like Price's memorable theological proposition: What does it mean to say "I believe the Bible?" How is that the same or different as saying, "I believe Hamlet, or, I believe the Illiad?"
Post a Comment
I am New Testament Tutor at St Mellitus College and St Paul's Theological Centre, London. I'm also a Visiting Lecturer at King's College London. Less well known is that I am also the original writer of the now famous song “Beans, beans, good for your heart…”, and inventor of the “you must have fallen out of the stupid/ugly tree” repertoire of insults. I am the main proponent of the Human Faecal Matter for Brains Opening in chess (actually not what I wanted to call my brilliant and original opening Knight manoeuvre 1.Na3, 2.Nc1), and I also claim to have independently discovered the haiku™ poetry form (© Copyright Chris Tilling 2007) without any help from the Japs. My blog, Chrisendom, is primarily occupied with biblical and theological themes – especially those Apostle Paul shaped, but I try as best as I can to squeeze in a decent amount of inappropriate baloney on the way.
View my complete profile